Identifying the potential organ donor: an audit of hospital deaths
- Helen Ingrid Opdam,
- William Silvester
- … show all 2 hide
Rent the article at a discount
Rent now* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.
Get AccessAbstract
Objective
To quantify the potential for organ donation in Victoria and identify missed opportunities for organ donation.
Design and setting
Prospective medical record audit of all deaths in 12 Victorian hospitals.
Measurements
Data on deaths, total potential donors, organ donors and outcome of requests for organ donation were collected. Patients in whom brain death was confirmed or likely to occur and in whom organ donation was not requested (unrealised potential donors) were classified by an independent panel. Rates of organ donation and unrealised donors were determined as a proportion of total potential donors and hospital deaths and the maximal potential organ donor rate was estimated.
Results
Of 5551 deaths, there were 112 potential donors, with 66 requests for organ donation resulting in 39 consents (consent rate of 59%) and 37 organ donors (33% of total potential donors; 0.7% of hospital deaths). Two consented potential donors did not donate due to failed physiological support (5%). There were 46 medically suitable unrealised potential donors; 3 with confirmed brain death. Approximately half of these patients had treatment withdrawn in the intensive care unit and half in the Emergency Department. The estimated maximal potential donor rate was 30 per million population.
Conclusions
The potential for organ donation in Victoria is relatively low compared with previous estimates in Australia and overseas. An increase in the organ donation rate may be possible through increasing consent and the identification and support of potential donors. This would require substantial changes in clinical practice that have resource and ethical implications.
- ANZOD Australia and New Zealand Organ Donation Registry 1998–2002 reports. www.anzdata.org.au/anzod/ANZODReport/anzodreport.htm Accessed 6 June 2003
- Matesanz, (2002) J Nephrol 15: pp. 22
- Nathan, (1991) Transplantation 51: pp. 142
- Hibberd, (1992) Br Med J 304: pp. 1339
- Gortmaker, (1996) Crit Care Med 24: pp. 432
- TSANZ (1998) Transplant Society of Australia and New Zealand, Australian national organ allocation protocols. Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
- ANZICS (1998) Recommendations concerning brain death and organ donation. www.anzics.com.au
- Roels, (2001) Prog Transplant 11: pp. 90
- Procaccio, (2001) Minerva Anestesiol 67: pp. 71
- Pugliese, (2002) Prog Transplant 12: pp. 275
- Dickerson, (2002) J Neurosurg 97: pp. 811
- Gore, (1992) Br Med J 304: pp. 349
- Gentleman, (1990) Br Med J 301: pp. 1203
- Thompson, (1995) Anaesth Intensive Care 23: pp. 75
- Miranda, (1997) Transplant Proc 29: pp. 1604 CrossRef
- Garrison, (1991) Surg Gynecol Obstet 173: pp. 391
- Sheehy, (1996) Transplant Proc 28: pp. 139
- Evans, (1992) J Am Med Assoc 267: pp. 239 CrossRef
- Navarro, (1996) Transplant Proc 28: pp. 103
- Siminoff, (1999) J Qual Improv 25: pp. 129
- Anonymous (1999) Road deaths. In: The Economist, p 106
- López-Navidad, (2001) Transplant Proc 33: pp. 795 CrossRef
- Matesanz, (1996) Transplant Proc 28: pp. 232
- Gubernatis, (1997) Transplant Proc 29: pp. 1489 CrossRef
- Santiago, (1997) Transplant Proc 29: pp. 1625 CrossRef
- Siminoff, (2001) J Am Med Assoc 286: pp. 71 CrossRef
- Gortmaker, (1998) J Transpl Coord 8: pp. 210
- Pearson, (1995) Anaesth Intensive Care 23: pp. 68
- Shafer, (1994) J Am Med Assoc 272: pp. 1607 CrossRef
- Ihle, (1993) Anaesth Intensive Care 21: pp. 710
- Espinel, (1989) Transplant Proc 21: pp. 1419
- Lopez-Navidad, (2002) Transplant Proc 34: pp. 20 CrossRef
- Chapman, (1995) Anaesth Intensive Care 23: pp. 81
- Skowronski, (1993) Med J Aust 159: pp. 358
- Siminoff, (1995) Ann Intern Med 123: pp. 10
- Salih, (1991) Br Med J 302: pp. 1053
- ONT Organización Nacional de Trasplantes website. http://www.msc.es/ont/esp/ accessed 22 July 2003
- Siminoff, (2001) Clin Transplant 15: pp. 39 CrossRef
- Bristow, (1999) Anaesth Intensive Care 27: pp. 91
- Title
- Identifying the potential organ donor: an audit of hospital deaths
- Journal
-
Intensive Care Medicine
Volume 30, Issue 7 , pp 1390-1397
- Cover Date
- 2004-07-01
- DOI
- 10.1007/s00134-004-2185-9
- Print ISSN
- 0342-4642
- Online ISSN
- 1432-1238
- Publisher
- Springer-Verlag
- Additional Links
- Keywords
-
- Organ donors
- Organ procurement
- Transplantation
- Brain death
- Medical Records
- Industry Sectors
- Authors
-
- Helen Ingrid Opdam (1) (2)
- William Silvester (1) (2)
- Author Affiliations
-
- 1. Department of Intensive Care, Austin Hospital, Studley Road, 3084, Heidelberg, Victoria, Australia
- 2. Victorian Organ Donation Service, Melbourne, Australia